An urgent call to states, donors and other stakeholders to promote and protect the rights of stateless persons in their COVID-19 responses
As governments across the world confront the COVID-19 pandemic, facing deeply challenging decisions on protecting public health while averting starvation and warding off economic disaster, it is increasingly evident that in times of crisis, states are largely embracing a “citizens first” approach. Denied nationality and deprived basic rights and welfare, the stateless were already marginalised before the crisis. They now face even greater, life-threatening marginalisation, with potentially disastrous consequences.
We, the undersigned 84 civil society actors, work on the right to nationality, non-discrimination, and statelessness around the world. We have been tracking and responding to the devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and state responses to it, on those whose nationality and belonging is denied or under threat. We have observed that in democratic states, measures including border closures and movement restrictions, health assistance, emergency relief and economic stimulus packages, privilege citizens and their concerns. Migrants, refugees, populations at risk of statelessness and the stateless themselves are left behind. Those without documentation to prove their citizenship or denied protection status are most at risk. Moreover, with rising authoritarianism, as leaders exploit the pandemic to grab more power, increase surveillance, and derogate from human rights obligations under declared states of emergency, non-citizens and members of minority groups – including those residing and rendered stateless in their own country – are increasingly scapegoated, vilified and targeted for hate-speech, arbitrary detention and even expulsion.
Most of the people and communities we work with endure discrimination, marginalisation and disadvantage under ‘normal’ circumstances. As the pandemic crisis takes its toll, the stateless are among those paying the highest of prices. Many face increased racism and xenophobia and are denied access to critical health services and information (in a language they understand) on prevention and treatment. Many are also fearful of seeking such assistance, as they are at-risk of being arrested, detained and subject to removal proceedings. Others are excluded from desperately needed emergency relief – as states require digital identity or documentation establishing proof of citizenship in order to administer relief. We are also concerned that measures that disrupt vital state functions such as birth and civil registration appear to be having knock-on effects for access to nationality and protection for marginalised groups. These dynamics could leave more people at risk of statelessness and exposed to its most pernicious consequences, even when the health of all people depends on the health of every individual, regardless of their legal status or lack thereof. Below are some examples:
On all continents, minorities and those deprived of documentation and citizenship, including Dominicans of Haitian origin, Indians declared foreigners in Assam, the Bidoon of Kuwait, the Maragoli, Nubians, Shona and Pemba communities of East Africa, and Europe’s Roma now face additional threats to their livelihoods and health, with many enduring heightened hate-speech, police violence and discrimination.
Women who are denied the equal right to confer citizenship on their children or spouses, face impossible choices as non-citizen family members are separated from them and/or denied COVID-19 relief.
Stateless people in densely populated camps, detention centres and informal settlements, as well as those in situations of homelessness and poverty, are at high risk of infection due to the inability to be protected through social distancing and preventative hygiene measures.
The Rohingya have endured new waves of hate speech in Malaysia, ongoing persecution in Myanmar and the first cases of COVID-19 have been reported in camps in Bangladesh, while a number of boats carrying Rohingya refugees have been denied safe and expedited disembarkation. As the crisis takes hold, it is evident that states are not taking full responsibility or providing adequate protection for this group, who have faced extraordinary persecution.
As we witness first-hand the cost of institutional and public blindness and structural violence towards the stateless (and those at risk of statelessness) as states respond to COVID-19, we are deeply concerned about the lasting impact on an estimated 15 million stateless persons worldwide, and tens of millions whose nationality is under threat. Without urgent attention, protection and intervention, from states, human rights and humanitarian actors and donors alike, the stateless face irreparable harm, undermining progress in addressing this urgent human rights issue over the last decade.
The COVID-19 pandemic highlights our collective and individual vulnerability, bringing into sharp focus the paramount importance of at all times promoting, protecting and fulfilling everyone’s universal human rights, wherever they may be and whatever status they may have. In addition to demanding urgent and immediate action, the crisis provokes longer-term introspection and highlights the need for structural change to dismantle discriminatory and degrading laws, policies and practices, which deny and deprive nationality while excluding, marginalising and penalising on this basis.
While acknowledging and welcoming emerging examples of good practice, we urge all stakeholders to take the following urgent actions:
1. States, to not discriminate in COVID-19 responses on any grounds including citizenship, documentation or migration status; to make every effort to reach the furthest behind first, including the stateless; and to ensure that no one’s right to nationality is undermined as a result of disruptions to registries or for any other reason.
2. UN agencies, including the WHO, WFP, UNHCR, OHCHR, UNICEF and UNDP to ensure that their COVID-19 responses identify and reach the stateless and other vulnerable and overlooked groups as a matter of priority, to provide them with critical information, healthcare and relief.
3. Human rights actors, including OHCHR, to maintain a spotlight on enduring discrimination, rising authoritarianism and harmful state practices such as police brutality in response to the COVID-19 pandemic; and to monitor and highlight rights violations faced by the stateless and those whose right to nationality is at risk.
4. Humanitarian actors, including the WFP, to identify and target emergency relief and aid to stateless and other vulnerable communities who are excluded from state relief efforts, in consultation with those working on these issues.
5. Public health actors, including the WHO and health ministries, to reinforce the importance of ensuring equal and adequate access to healthcare and public health information to all, regardless of nationality or statelessness, without fear of arrest, detention or reprisal.
6. Media and social media actors, to act responsibly, only publish verified information, counter xenophobia and hate speech and take decisive action against those who abuse media platforms to provoke hatred and prejudice against the stateless, migrants, minorities and other marginalised groups.
7. Donors, to support stateless communities, the crucial work of activists and grassroots groups, as well as the tracking, coordination and advocacy conducted at national, regional and international levels, to provide for and draw attention to the needs of stateless persons at this time.
Most importantly, we remind all stakeholders of the imperative to listen to, work with and be guided by stateless activists and communities, and to be accountable to them for actions and inaction, during this time of crisis and beyond.
While the price already paid has been immense, we hope that through urgent and concerted action, we will together be able to promote a rights-based, inclusive and non-discriminatory response to COVID-19, based on the premise that no one – including the stateless – should be left behind. We stand ready to share information and work with all stakeholders in furtherance of this goal.
Aditus Foundation, Malta
Americas Network on Nationality and Statelessness
Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network
Asian Federation Against Involuntary Disappearances (AFAD)
Bahrain Women Union
Bangladesh Institute of Human Rights (BIHR)
Beyond Borders Malaysia
Burmese Rohingya Organisation UK
Canadian Centre on Statelessness (CCS)
Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL)
Central Asian Network on Statelessness
Centre for Advancement of Development Rights (CEADER), Nigeria
Charitable fund “Right to Protection” (R2P), Ukraine
Citizens Against Hate
Citizenship Affected People’s Network, Nepal
Coalition de la Société Civile Ivoirienne Contre l’Apatridie (CICA), Côte D’Ivoire
Collective for Research and Training
on Development-Action (CRTDA) – My Nationality is A Right for Me and My Family Campaign
Conscience International Sierra Leone (CISL)
Development and Justice Initiative (DAJI), India
Development of Human Resource for Rural Areas (DHRRA), Malaysia
Dominican@s por Derecho Platform, Dominican Republic
East Africa Nationality Network
Equal Rights Trust
European Network on Statelessness
Families of Victims of Involuntary Disappearance (FIND), Philippines
Focus Development Association, Madagascar
Foreign Spouses Support Group (FSSG), Malaysia
Forum for Women, Law and Development, Nepal
Fundación Cepaim Acción Integral con Migrantes, Spain
Foundation for Access to Rights (FAR), Bulgaria
Global Campaign for Equal Nationality Rights
Gulf Institute for Democracy and Human Rights (GIDHR), Australia
Haki Centre, Kenya
Indonesian Legal Aid Association for Women (APIK)
Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion
International Campaign for the Rohingya
International Commission of Jurists
International Detention Coalition
International Observatory of Human Rights
International Refugee Rights Initiative
Justice & Equality Forum, UK
Kenya Human Rights Commission
Kuwaiti Bedoons Movement
Lawyers for Human Rights, South Africa
Malaysian Campaign for Equal Citizenship (MCEC)
MENA Rights Group
MENA Statelessness Network (Hawiati)
Minority Rights Group International
Minority Rights Organization
Mosawa Network, Jordan
Movimiento Reconoci.do, Dominican Republic
Muslim Engagement and Development (MEND), UK
New Women Connectors, Europe
Nubian Rights Forum, Kenya
Observatory Caribbean Migrants (OBMICA), Dominican Republic
Our Journey, Malaysia
Rencontre Africaine pour la Défense des Droits de l’Homme (RADDHO), Senegal
Rights Realization Centre
Rohingya Human Rights Network, Canada
Roma Youth Organization “Walk with us – Phiren amenca”
Ruwad alHoukouk FR, Lebanon
Salam for Democracy and Human Rights
Southern African Nationality Network
Statelessness Network Asia Pacific
Swedish Organization Against Statelessness (SOAS)
The Arab Women Organization of Jordan (AWO)
The Arakan Project, Myanmar
The Brunei Project
The Omani Association for Human Rights
Tirana Legal Aid Society (TLAS)
United Stateless, USA
Voice of the Children, Malaysia
Women Peace Network
Women’s Refugee Commission (WRC)